Maytag Ice Maker Comparison: Analyzing Specifications and Compatibility
A failing maytag ice maker causes frustrating disruptions, leading to frozen ejector blades, unharvested cubes, or persistent water leaks inside the freezer compartment. Choosing the right maytag ice maker replacement requires verifying part numbers, wire harness pinouts, voltage ratings, and harvest mold dimensions before ordering. Installing an incompatible maytag refrigerator ice maker assembly can damage…
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
A failing maytag ice maker causes frustrating disruptions, leading to frozen ejector blades, unharvested cubes, or persistent water leaks inside the freezer compartment. Choosing the right maytag ice maker replacement requires verifying part numbers, wire harness pinouts, voltage ratings, and harvest mold dimensions before ordering. Installing an incompatible maytag refrigerator ice maker assembly can damage the water inlet solenoid or result in total cycling failure. Knowing whether your appliance relies on an optical sensor or a physical shutoff arm ensures your refrigerator returns to consistent ice production.
This guide provides an exhaustive maytag ice maker comparison covering 3 replacement units: the 2198597 Ice Maker, the W10882923 Refrigerator Ice Maker for Whirlpool, and the W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly. While all 3 units restore ice generation, they differ in electrical draw, mold capacity, structural materials, and shutoff detection methods. Wattage ranges from a 185-watt thermal release model to an ultra-efficient 9.2-watt motorized polymer unit, while reservoir capacities span 130 ml to 1.5 pounds. Reviewing these mechanical specifications reveals which maytag ice maker to buy for your freezer configuration.
Which Maytag Ice Maker Should You Buy
- Choose the 2198597 Ice Maker if your cabinet uses an optical level sensor and requires a high-draw 185-watt thermal harvest mold.
- Choose the W10882923 Refrigerator Ice Maker for Whirlpool if you need a compact 130 ml tray with a dedicated motor and included installation instructions.
- Choose the W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly if you require an ultra-low 9.2-watt power draw, frost-resistant polymer housing, and broad W11700250 part compatibility.
2198597 Ice Maker
Price not listed
Our score: 8.6/10Mostly positive
Brand Nurfosttek ASIN B0GF1PHY7L
Best for: Optical sensor freezers needing high-power harvest
Pros
- 185W mold heater for rapid ice release
- Produces 8 cubes per cycle
- Direct replacement for W10122502 and 2198678
Cons
- Lacks mechanical shutoff arm
- High 185-watt electrical draw
The 2198597 Ice Maker is a dedicated replacement unit engineered for domestic refrigerators that utilize electronic bin sensing. Built under part number RIM597, this module operates on standard household alternating current at 115 volts and 60 Hz. Its primary performance metric is an integrated 185-watt mold heater that warms the aluminum tray during harvest to release 8 ice cubes per cycle. This rapid heating design solves common refrigerator failures such as frozen ejector fingers, abnormal ice shapes, and stalling cycles.
Sized at 4.59 inches deep, 11.42 inches wide, and 4.78 inches high, this 1-liter assembly is manufactured from food-grade materials that comply with hygiene standards. It operates safely in sub-zero freezer environments charged with R600a refrigerant. A crucial operational detail from the listing is that this unit does not include a lifting arm. It is designed to function strictly in conjunction with cabinet-mounted optical sensors. Installing this model into a refrigerator that requires a mechanical shutoff arm will lead to unmonitored ice production and bin overflow.
When checking maytag ice maker compatibility, this module provides direct cross-referencing for legacy part numbers W10122502, 626663, 1016069, and 2198678. Much like the troubleshooting process detailed in our lg icemaker replacement guide, confirming electrical harness pinouts before installation ensures seamless operation. This unit fits over one hundred refrigerator models, including JCB2488MTR00, JCB2581WES00, JCB2585WEP00, JCB2585WES00, and JCD2395WES00. If your appliance has optical level sensing and requires a high-wattage 115V harvest, the 2198597 ice maker provides an exact mechanical fit.
- Equipped with a 185-watt heater delivering 8 ice cubes per harvest cycle
- Manufactured with food-grade materials compatible with R600a cooling systems
- Replaces legacy part numbers W10122502, 626663, 1016069, and 2198678
- Engineered for sensor-governed freezers and omits a mechanical shutoff arm
W10882923 Refrigerator Ice Maker for Whirlpool
Price not listed
Our score: 9.0/10Very positive
Brand Frigeswift ASIN B0G5PTCSHS
Best for: French door freezers replacing legacy units
Pros
- High-efficiency motor prevents gear jams
- Detailed illustrated installation guide included
- Broad replacement for W10882923 and WPW10377151
Cons
- Listing omits operational wattage
- Compact 130 ml tray capacity
The W10882923 Refrigerator Ice Maker for Whirlpool is built for bottom-freezer and French-door refrigerators experiencing drive motor failure or severe ice jams. Measuring 11.6 inches deep, 4.6 inches wide, and 5 inches high, this replacement unit features a 130 ml capacity tray. Powered by 115-volt alternating current, it integrates a high-efficiency drive motor constructed to maintain steady torque and prevent stripped gears. Homeowners dealing with undersized ice cubes, continuous motor clicking, or appliance error codes can restore normal harvest cycles with this unit.
This assembly provides strong cross-compatibility across multiple refrigeration platforms. The w10882923 ice maker directly replaces part numbers W10882923, RIM2923, W10377151, W10377147, WPW10377151, and WPW10377147. While the listing does not specify its exact operational wattage, the assembly incorporates durable composite components certified for R600a refrigerant atmospheres. Similar to diagnostic principles reviewed in our frigidaire nugget icemaker analysis, verifying inlet water pressure before mounting avoids splashing and uneven freezing across the mold.
Installation of this module is tailored for do-it-yourself repair. The package includes a detailed illustrated installation guide and all necessary mounting hardware, allowing users to mount the unit with standard hand tools. By addressing ejector stalling and erratic internal switching, this assembly restores factory-grade freezing without cabinet rewiring. For refrigerators with 4.6-inch mounting widths that require a 130 ml tray, this replacement provides dependable daily ice production.
- Directly replaces part numbers W10882923, RIM2923, W10377151, and WPW10377147
- Features a high-efficiency electric motor to prevent gear jams and harvest stalls
- Built with durable materials compatible with sealed R600a refrigeration circuits
- Includes an illustrated installation guide and mounting hardware for self-repair
W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly
Price not listed
Our score: 9.0/10Very positive
Brand Zanbwgqd ASIN B0G6JRG3DV
Best for: Energy-conscious households needing frost-resistant construction
Pros
- Ultra-low 9.2W power consumption
- Frost-resistant polymer construction
- Large 1.5-pound holding capacity
Cons
- Plastic body rather than metal mold
The W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly is an energy-conscious replacement module built around the W11700250 engineering standard. Measuring 3 inches deep, 11.7 inches wide, and 5.1 inches high, this assembly provides a generous 1.5-pound ice holding capacity. Operating at 115V AC at 60 Hz with a minimal 0.08-ampere current draw, this maytag fridge ice maker module consumes only 9.2 watts of power. This ultra-low wattage reduces heat generation inside the freezer, preserving stable cabinet temperatures and lowering electrical wear on internal components.
Material durability is a primary advantage of this design. Molded from frost-resistant polymer material, this assembly withstands sub-zero temperatures and high humidity without warping, cracking, or deforming over extended use. This rigid polymer construction prevents ice blockages and eliminates loud grinding noises during ejection. The precision-engineered mechanical system produces clear, uniform ice cubes cycle after cycle, making it a reliable solution for busy households requiring steady ice output.
Cross-referencing for the w11546935 ice maker assembly includes a wide range of part numbers. It directly replaces W11359448, W11633658, W11546935, 3909DB, 4963738, AP7019172, AP7219248, EAP16555339, EAP17216974, PS16555339, PS17216974, NTXA001WF1, AWP46686, and PD00087223. Similar to control board validation covered in our magic chef ice maker breakdown, verifying wiring plug compatibility ensures a one-to-one swap with no wire cutting required. For appliances needing a 9.2-watt low-profile module, this polymer assembly delivers long-term reliability.
- Operates at an ultra-low 9.2 watts and 0.08 amperes on standard 115V AC power
- Molded from frost-resistant polymer that resists low-temperature cracking and warping
- Delivers a 1.5-pound holding capacity with uniform, clear ice cube harvesting
- Replaces numerous part numbers including W11700250, W11359448, and W11633658
What Sets These Models Apart
| Model Name | Electrical Specifications | Dimensions (D x W x H) | Stated Capacity | Primary Part Numbers Replaced |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2198597 Ice Maker | 185 Watts, 115V AC, 60Hz | 4.59″D x 11.42″W x 4.78″H | 1 Liter (8 cubes per cycle) | W10122502, 626663, 1016069, 2198678 |
| W10882923 Refrigerator Ice Maker for Whirlpool | 115V AC (wattage not specified) | 11.6″D x 4.6″W x 5″H | 130 ml | W10882923, RIM2923, W10377151, WPW10377147 |
| W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly | 9.2 Watts, 115V AC, 0.08A | 3″D x 11.7″W x 5.1″H | 1.5 Pounds | W11700250, W11359448, W11633658, AP7019172 |
Buying Tips for Maytag Ice Maker Units
When preparing to purchase a replacement module, always locate your true maytag ice maker part number on the refrigerator cabinet data sticker. Many homeowners make the error of copying the number molded onto the plastic housing or aluminum body of the failed unit. Those embossed numbers frequently denote raw part casting numbers rather than the functional electrical assembly. Checking the serial tag inside the fresh food compartment or along the lower door frame ensures you find the matching service part number for your specific appliance revision.
Understanding shutoff detection is equally vital for proper maytag ice maker compatibility. Certain freezers use a metal wire bail arm that rises as ice accumulates, stopping the motor switch when full. Other models utilize infrared emitter beams across the ice bin cavity. If your cabinet uses optical sensing, an armless unit like the 2198597 ice maker integrates directly. However, installing an armless module into a freezer that lacks optical sensors will cause unmonitored harvesting that overflows the bin and blocks the freezer door.
Finally, examine electrical ratings and wiring harness configurations before attempting installation. A high-draw 185-watt unit relies on an internal heater to release cubes, whereas a 9.2-watt unit operates via low-power motorized ejection. Forcing an incompatible plug into a mismatched freezer harness can short the main control board or ruin the water fill solenoid. Always disconnect power at the household breaker and shut off the water supply valve before removing mounting screws to ensure safe installation.