Skip to the story

Shopping notes on tools, kitchens and the smart home

TierWay.net

Fishing Kayaks

Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

Find 6 similar kayak alternatives to the Old Town Sportsman PDL 120. We compare published specs like weight, length, and capacity to help you choose the right vessel.

Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

You might be looking for old town sportsman pdl 120 pedal alternatives if you need a different size, weight, or propulsion method. The original model offers a 12-foot pontoon hull with a 500-pound capacity and a 116-pound weight, making it a stable solo fishing platform. It includes a pedal drive and an adjustable mesh seat for hands-free navigation. However, you may prefer a lighter boat for transport or a tandem model for a partner. Some buyers also seek motorized options or a shorter 10.5-foot hull for easier storage. We selected 6 similar picks because their published specifications overlap with the original. This list compares boats that share key traits like solo seating, fishing activity, and similar lengths. You can find options with different widths, weights, or drive systems. Each alternative matches the core use case while offering distinct physical attributes. This guide helps you compare specs directly to find the best fit for your specific needs.

How Each Alternative Compares

BKC Brooklyn 12.0 Pedal Fishing Kayak

The BKC Brooklyn 12.0 matches the 12-foot length but weighs only 75 pounds, significantly lighter than the 116-pound Old Town. It offers a 33.5-inch width compared to the 36-inch pontoon hull, providing slightly less initial stability but improved maneuverability. This model includes a rudder system for better tracking in wind or current, a feature absent in the standard PDL 120. While it lacks the pontoon-style hull design, it provides pedal propulsion for hands-free operation. You should choose this if you prioritize easy transport and precise steering over maximum payload capacity. The lower weight makes it ideal for solo anglers who hike or carry their kayak frequently.

Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak

The Old Town Sportsman 106 Motorized Kayak is shorter at 10.5 feet and heavier at 121 pounds. It replaces the pedal drive with a 45-pound thrust electric motor, offering a different propulsion method for those who prefer not to pedal. The hull is designed for easy electronics installation, making it suitable for anglers who rely heavily on fish finders. While it sacrifices the hands-free efficiency of pedaling, it provides quiet, precise electric control. This model is best for solo anglers who want a compact platform with integrated motor mounting. You should pick this if you value electric power and shorter length for easier storage and handling over the extended range of a 12-foot pedal kayak.

Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Fishing Kayak

The Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Kayak is a compact version at 10.5 feet, weighing just 18 pounds without the pedal console. It shares the pontoon-style hull and pedal drive technology of the 120 model, ensuring similar stability and hands-free operation. The reduced length makes it easier to transport and maneuver in tight spaces. However, it offers less deck space for gear and a shorter tracking line. You should choose this if you need a more portable pedal kayak without sacrificing the stability of the pontoon design. It is ideal for solo anglers who prioritize ease of transport and manageable size over the extended storage and range of the 12-foot model.

BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak

The BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Kayak is designed for two or three people, offering significantly more seating capacity than the solo PDL 120. It weighs 70 pounds, making it lighter than the 116-pound Old Town, despite its larger size. The 32-inch width provides good stability, while the 12-foot 2-inch length offers ample deck space for gear and passengers. This model includes a motor mount for future upgrades, allowing you to switch from paddling or pedaling to electric power. You should pick this if you frequently fish with a partner or need extra space for heavy gear. It is less suitable for solo anglers who prefer the specialized comfort and stability of a single-person pontoon hull.

BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak

The BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak is the longest and heaviest option at 153 inches and 89.9 pounds. It supports two or three people, offering vastly more capacity than the solo PDL 120. The 34.3-inch width provides exceptional stability for tandem fishing or heavy gear loads. This model features adjustable seating, allowing you to customize the layout for comfort and efficiency. While it lacks pedal propulsion, its size and weight capacity make it ideal for families or groups. You should choose this if you need maximum space and stability for shared trips. It is not suitable for solo anglers who prefer the maneuverability and specialized design of a single-person kayak.

Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized

The Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized Kayak is identical in length to the PDL 120 but weighs 150 pounds, significantly heavier due to its integrated electric motor. It replaces the pedal drive with an electric propulsion system, offering quiet and precise control for solo anglers. The 37-inch width provides slightly more stability than the 36-inch PDL 120. This model is designed for those who prefer electric power over manual pedaling, offering hands-free operation without physical exertion. You should pick this if you want the stability of a pontoon hull with the convenience of electric drive. It is less suitable for anglers who prioritize lightweight transport or prefer the efficiency of pedal propulsion.

#ProductBest forPrice
1Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal Kayak Best overallSolo anglers seeking stable pedal propulsion
2BKC Brooklyn 12.0 Pedal Fishing Kayak Best budgetsolo anglers needing pedal stability
3Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak Best 10.5 ftSolo anglers wanting easy motorized setup
4Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Fishing Kayak Best premiumSolo anglers needing stable, hands-free pedal propulsion
5BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak Best motor mountTandem fishing trips with motor upgrade potential
6BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak Best adjustable lengthTandem fishing with heavy gear loads
7Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized Also greatSolo anglers preferring electric drive
1Best overall
Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal Kayak

Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal Kayak

Best for: Solo anglers seeking stable pedal propulsion

Length
12 ft
Weight Capacity
500 lbs
Seating Capacity
Solo
Propulsion Type
Pedal drive
Seat Type
Adjustable mesh seat
Activity
Fishing

The Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 is a 12-foot solo fishing kayak with a 500-pound weight capacity. It uses a forward and reverse pedal drive for hands-free navigation. The pontoon-style hull provides stability, while the adjustable mesh seat offers lumbar support. This model suits anglers who need a stable platform for gear and personal comfort on the water.

Pros
  • 500-pound maximum weight capacity
  • Forward and reverse pedal drive system
  • Adjustable mesh seat with lumbar support
  • Pontoon-style hull for stability
  • Universal transducer mounting system
Cons
  • Solo seating capacity limits group use
  • 116-pound weight is heavy for transport
  • Lower usable capacity than tandem models
Good fit if
  • You prioritize stability for solo fishing trips
  • You need a pedal drive for hands-free operation
  • You require a seat with adjustable lumbar support
Skip if
  • You need to carry two or more people
  • You prefer a lighter kayak for easy carrying
  • You want a motorized propulsion system

Verdict: Old Town Sportsman PDL 120 offers a stable, hands-free fishing experience for solo anglers. It fits buyers who value pedal propulsion and a comfortable, adjustable seat for long days on the water.

2Best budget
BKC Brooklyn 12.0 Pedal Fishing Kayak

BKC Brooklyn 12.0 Pedal Fishing Kayak

Best for: solo anglers needing pedal stability

Deck Type
Sit-on-Top
Length
144 inches
Weight Capacity
440 lb
Seating Capacity
Single
Hull Material
HDPE
Propulsion Type
pedal drive

This 12-foot sit-on-top kayak features a high-efficiency propeller pedal system with a hand-operated rudder for precise steering. The 33.5-inch wide HDPE hull provides stability in chop or current. It supports a single angler with a 440 lb weight capacity. The aluminum frame seat offers ergonomic support for all-day fishing. This model suits those seeking a stable, pedal-driven platform for flatwater or coastal exploration.

Pros
  • High-efficiency propeller pedal drive with bicycle-style pedals
  • Hand-operated rudder steering for tight turns
  • 33.5-inch wide HDPE hull for excellent stability
  • 440 lb weight capacity for gear and angler
  • Aluminum frame seat for breathable all-day support
Cons
  • 440 lb weight capacity is lower than the 600 lb and 800 lb options on this list
  • Single-person seating limits group outings compared to the tandem models available
Good fit if
  • You want a stable, single-angler kayak with pedal propulsion
  • You prioritize rudder steering control and hull stability over maximum load capacity
  • You plan to fish in flatwater or moderate chop without needing tandem space
Skip if
  • You need to carry two or more people on a single vessel
  • You require a higher weight capacity than 440 lb for heavy gear or larger anglers
  • You prefer motorized propulsion over a pedal drive system

Verdict: BKC Brooklyn 12.0 Single Pedal Kayak is a practical choice for solo anglers who value pedal efficiency and rudder control over the higher capacity of tandem models. It fits you if you need a stable, single-person platform for focused fishing trips.

3Best 10.5 ft
Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak

Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak

Best for: Solo anglers wanting easy motorized setup

Length
10 ft 6 in
Weight Capacity
525-pound
Seating Capacity
Solo
Propulsion Type
Motorized
Seat Type
dual-layer Textilene mesh seat
Activity
Fishing

This 10.5 ft solo fishing kayak features a Minn Kota 45-pound thrust trolling motor. It has a 525-pound max capacity and weighs 121 pounds. The dual-layer Textilene seat and large rudder aid comfort and control. You get three through-hull wiring kits for electronics. It suits anglers wanting motorized ease in a compact, solo-friendly hull.

Pros
  • 45-pound thrust Minn Kota trolling motor
  • 525-pound maximum weight capacity
  • Extra-large rudder for steering control
  • Dual-layer Textilene mesh seat
  • Three through-hull wiring kits included
Cons
  • 121-pound weight is heavier than non-motorized peers
  • 525-pound capacity is lower than 600 or 800-pound tandem options
  • 10.5-foot length is shorter than 12-foot alternatives
Good fit if
  • You want motorized propulsion without drilling
  • You fish solo in calm waters
  • You need a compact hull for transport
Skip if
  • You require pedal drive propulsion
  • You need to carry two or more people
  • You prefer a longer, more stable platform

Verdict: Old Town Sportsman 106 Motorized Kayak fits solo anglers who value the convenience of a 45-pound thrust motor and a manageable 10.5-foot length. It is a practical option for those prioritizing easy electronics installation over maximum payload.

4Best premium
Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Fishing Kayak

Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Fishing Kayak

Best for: Solo anglers needing stable, hands-free pedal propulsion

Length
10-foot, 6-inch
Weight Capacity
450-pound
Seating Capacity
solo
Propulsion Type
pedal drive
Seat Type
mesh seat
Activity
Fishing

This 10-foot 6-inch solo fishing kayak uses a forward and reverse pedal drive for hands-free navigation. It features a pontoon-style hull for stability and a 450-pound weight capacity. The 36-inch width and 107-pound total weight make it manageable for car topping. You get a mesh seat with lumbar support and customizable accessory tracks. It suits anglers who want stable, quiet performance in a compact package.

Pros
  • Forward and reverse pedal drive for hands-free control
  • 450-pound maximum weight capacity
  • Stable pontoon-style hull design
  • 36-inch width for improved balance
  • Customizable accessory tracks and rod holders
Cons
  • 107-pound total weight is heavier than lighter alternatives
  • 10-foot 6-inch length offers less tracking than 12-foot models
  • Solo seating limits group fishing trips
Good fit if
  • You need a stable, single-person kayak for solo fishing trips
  • You want hands-free propulsion via a forward and reverse pedal drive
  • You prefer a pontoon-style hull for quiet, stable paddling
Skip if
  • You require a tandem kayak for fishing with a partner
  • You need a vessel longer than 10 feet 6 inches for open water
  • You prefer a motorized setup over a manual pedal drive system

Verdict: Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Kayak provides a stable, solo platform for anglers who value pontoon-style stability and hands-free pedal propulsion. It fits single anglers who prioritize stability and manageable weight over the extended range of longer, tandem models.

5Best motor mount
BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak

BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak

Best for: Tandem fishing trips with motor upgrade potential

Deck Type
Sit-on-Top
Length
12.5 ft
Weight Capacity
600 lbs
Seating Capacity
2 to 3 Person
Hull Material
HDPE
Propulsion Type
Paddle, motor-ready

This 12.5-foot sit-on-top kayak seats two to three people with a 600-pound capacity. It features a 34-inch beam for stability and includes two padded seats and paddles. The design accommodates a trolling motor mount, offering flexibility for solo or tandem fishing trips on lakes or calm rivers.

Pros
  • 600-pound weight capacity for heavy gear or passengers
  • Includes two padded seats and two paddles
  • Six rod holders (four flush, two articulating)
  • 34-inch beam provides high stability
  • Built-in trolling motor mount area
Cons
  • 70-pound weight is heavier than single-person alternatives
  • 32-inch width is narrower than the 34-inch beam of some competitors
  • 600-pound capacity is lower than the 800-pound tandem option on this list
Good fit if
  • You need a tandem kayak for two adults and a child
  • You want a stable platform for standing casts
  • You plan to add a trolling motor later
Skip if
  • You prefer a lighter, single-person vessel
  • You require a higher weight capacity than 600 pounds
  • You want a wider beam for maximum stability

Verdict: BKC Brooklyn 12.5 Tandem Fishing Kayak fits anglers who need extra space and stability for tandem trips or heavy gear loads. It is ideal for those who plan to upgrade to motorized propulsion without buying a new hull.

6Best adjustable length
BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak

BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak

Best for: Tandem fishing with heavy gear loads

Length
153 inches
Weight Capacity
800 lb
Seating Capacity
2 to 3 person
Seat Type
adjustable aluminum frame
Activity
Fishing
Features
Rod Holders, Adjustable Length

The BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro is a tandem fishing kayak with an 800 lb weight capacity. It features adjustable aluminum frame seats and footrests for customizable comfort. The 153-inch length and 34.3-inch width provide a stable platform for two to three people. You can reconfigure the center seat for solo use. This model includes rod holders and dry hatches for gear storage.

Pros
  • 800 lb weight capacity supports heavy loads
  • Adjustable aluminum frame seats for ergonomic comfort
  • 153-inch length offers ample paddling space
  • Versatile setup for two, three, or solo use
Cons
  • Heavier build at 89.9 pounds compared to solo models
  • Wider 34.3-inch beam reduces tracking speed
Good fit if
  • You need high stability for fishing with a partner
  • You require adjustable seating for better visibility
  • You want to carry significant gear or a child
Skip if
  • You prioritize lightweight portability for solo trips
  • You prefer a narrower hull for faster paddling
  • You only need a single-person vessel

Verdict: BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem provides exceptional stability and load capacity for anglers sharing the water. It suits pairs or families who value adjustable comfort and gear space over speed.

7Also great
Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized

Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized

Best for: Solo anglers preferring electric drive

Deck Type
Sit-on-Top
Length
12 ft
Seating Capacity
Solo
Propulsion Type
Minn Kota Motor
Activity
Fishing
Color
Camo

This 12-foot sit-on-top kayak uses a Minn Kota motor for propulsion. It is designed for solo fishing with a 37-inch width and 150-pound weight. The hull features four 18-inch accessory tracks and flush-mount rod holders. You get a large rudder for control. This motorized option suits anglers who prefer electric power over manual pedaling.

Pros
  • Minn Kota motor propulsion
  • 12-foot length for stability
  • 37-inch width for capacity
  • Four 18-inch accessory tracks
  • Large rudder for control
Cons
  • 150-pound weight is heavy for transport
  • Solo seating limits group use
  • Motorized system requires battery maintenance
Good fit if
  • You want electric propulsion without pedaling
  • You fish solo in calm waters
  • You need extensive accessory mounting tracks
Skip if
  • You need a tandem kayak for two people
  • You prefer manual pedal drive systems
  • You require a lightweight boat under 100 pounds

Verdict: Old Town Sportsman AutoPilot 120 offers reliable motorized control for solo anglers. It fits those who prioritize electric power and accessory space over manual pedaling or tandem capacity.

Specifications side by side

SpecOld Town Sportsman PDL 120 Pedal KayakBKC Brooklyn 12.0 Pedal Fishing KayakOld Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized KayakOld Town Sportsman PDL 106 Pedal Fishing KayakBKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing KayakBKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem KayakOld Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized
Deck Type–Sit-on-Top––Sit-on-Top–Sit-on-Top
Length12 ft144 inches10 ft 6 in10-foot, 6-inch12.5 ft153 inches12 ft
Weight Capacity500 lbs440 lb525-pound450-pound600 lbs800 lb–
Seating CapacitySoloSingleSolosolo2 to 3 Person2 to 3 personSolo
Hull Material–HDPE––HDPE––
Propulsion TypePedal drivepedal driveMotorizedpedal drivePaddle, motor-ready–Minn Kota Motor
Seat TypeAdjustable mesh seataluminum frame seatdual-layer Textilene mesh seatmesh seatPadded seatsadjustable aluminum frame–
ActivityFishingFishingFishingFishingFishingFishingFishing
Features–Rod Holders, Rudder, Pedal Drive––Rod Holders, Motor MountRod Holders, Adjustable Length–
Included Accessories–Seat––SeatSeat–
ColorCamoCamoCamoCamoCamoCamoCamo
Dimensions144 × 36 × 18 inches144 × 33.5 × 15 inches–126 × 36 × 14 inches148 × 32 × 12 inches153 × 34.3 × 18 inches144 × 37 × 25 inches
Weight116 pounds75 pounds121 pounds18 pounds70 pounds89.9 pounds150 pounds
SizeLength 12 Ft–Length 10 FtLength 10 Ft12-foot 2-inch–Length 12 Ft
Model01.4071.0103–01.4064.010301.4072.0103UH-TK219 CAMOPADPRO13T-UG-CAMO201.4065.0109

Frequently asked questions

Which pedal kayak is the lightest 12-foot alternative?

The BKC Brooklyn 12.0 is the lightest 12-foot option on this list. It weighs 75 pounds, which is significantly less than the 116-pound Old Town Sportsman PDL 120. This model also features a 33.5-inch width and includes a pedal drive and rudder for solo anglers seeking easier transport and handling.

Is there a shorter Old Town pedal kayak available?

Yes, the Old Town Sportsman PDL 106 is a 10.5-foot pedal alternative. It maintains the pontoon-style stability of the PDL 120 but in a more compact package. This model weighs 18 pounds and offers hands-free propulsion for solo anglers who prioritize stability and manageable weight over extended range.

Can I upgrade a BKC kayak with a motor?

The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 Tandem Kayak is designed for motor upgrades. It includes a dedicated motor mount and offers a 32-inch width for stability. This 12-foot 2-inch kayak supports two or three people and weighs 70 pounds, making it a practical choice for anglers who plan to add electric propulsion later.

What is the widest kayak in this comparison?

The Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized has the widest hull at 37 inches. It is a 12-foot sit-on-top kayak weighing 150 pounds. This width provides substantial stability for solo anglers who prefer electric drive over manual pedaling and need ample accessory space for their fishing gear.

Which kayak offers the best adjustable length for tandem fishing?

The BKC Brooklyn 13.0 Pro Tandem Kayak features an adjustable length design. It measures 153 inches long and 34.3 inches wide, offering exceptional stability for pairs or families. This model weighs 89.9 pounds and includes rod holders and seats, making it ideal for heavy gear loads and shared fishing trips.

Is there a motorized Old Town option similar to the PDL 120?

The Old Town AutoPilot 120 Motorized is the direct electric alternative. It shares the 12-foot length and 144-inch size of the PDL 120 but uses an electric drive instead of pedals. Weighing 150 pounds with a 25-inch height, it suits anglers who prioritize reliable motorized control and accessory space.

See also